Best places to get pizza in Fort Myers

Every Friday night we love having a family pizza and movie night! The kids get to pick out the movie we are going to watch and we spend time as a family.

And who doesn’t love pizza, am I right?

I love the chain pizza places like Papa John’s and Pizza Hut but I also love shopping local. Local Pizza just tastes better, I don’t know what it is but it just tastes better! And, lucky for us…there are so many pizza places in southwest Florida!

I decided to put together a list of the best local pizza places in Fort Myers. I have compiled a list based off of places that I love and what people recommended in various Facebook groups, including our very own Moms Exploring Southwest Florida group (Hop over and join our community!).

Disclaimer: Make sure you call ahead to make sure the hours of operation are accurate. I checked these myself but they are subject to change based on season and time of year. Some of these do dine in, carry out, and delivery but some do not offer all of these things, so please call and check in advance before making your decision. Thank you for your ongoing support of Mom Explores Southwest Florida! 

Be sure to click each restaurant name to hop over to their website and get more information!

Best Pizza Places in Fort Myers

Amore Brick Oven Pizza (Gulf Coast)

Located at 9903 Gulf Coast Main St. in Fort Myers. (239) 437-8800

Hours are:

Sundays 12-7PM
Monday-Thursday 11AM-9PM
Friday and Saturdays 11AM-10PM

Amore Brick Oven Pizza (North Fort Myers)

Located at 4353 Hancock Bridge Pkwy. in North Fort Myers. (239) 217-0584

Pickup Hours are:

Monday – Saturday 11AM-8:30PM

Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders

Located at 9377 Six Mile Cypress Pkwy. Suite 145 in Fort Myers. (239) 277-0600.

Hours are:

Monday – Thursday 10AM-9PM
Friday – Saturday 10AM-10PM
Sunday 11AM-9PM

Blue Moon Pizza

Located at 7381 College Parkway in Fort Myers. (239) 936-2583

Hours are:

Monday – Thursday 11AM-10PM
Friday 11AM-11PM
Saturday 11AM-10PM
Sunday 11AM-9PM

Citrola’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

The two locations in Fort Myers are:

8841 College Parkway in Fort Myers
16740 McGregor Blvd. in Fort Myers

Hours are:

Monday – Thursday 11AM-9PM
Friday 11AM-10PM
Saturday 3PM-10PM
Sunday 3PM-9PM

Downtown House of Pizza

1520 Hendry Street Downtown in Fort Myers. (239) 337-3467

Hours are:

Sunday – Wednesday 11AM-10PM
Thursday – Saturday 11AM-3AM

Fine Folk Pizza & Restaurant 

Located at 11300 Lindbergh Blvd. #114 Store #19 in Fort Myers. Dine in, pick up, and free delivery! (239) 313-5155.

Hours are:

Tuesday – Sunday 11AM-9PM
Mondays are closed.


Coal brick-oven pizzeria. Located at 13499 South Cleveland Ave., Suite 201 in Fort Myers. (239) 432-9767

Hours are:

Sunday – Thursday 11AM-10PM
Friday and Saturday 11AM-11PM

Il Forno Pasta & Pizza

Located at 3268 Forum Blvd. in Fort Myers. (239) 275-7777

Hours are:

Monday – Saturday 11AM-9PM
Sunday is closed

Jet’s Pizza

They have three locations around Fort Myers:

Jet’s Pizza Estero is located at 10011 Estero Town Commons Place (239) 495-5387

Jet’s Pizza Fort Myers is located at 13550 Reflections Pkwy. (239) 301-4800

Jet’s Pizza Bonita Springs is located at 3300 Bonita Beach Road, Suite 119. (239)301-3270

Hours for all three locations are:

Monday – Thursday 11AM-10PM
Friday – Saturday 11AM-11PM
Sunday noon – 10PM.

McGregor Pizza

Open every day offering delivery or dine-in. Located at 4600 McGregor Blvd. in Fort Myers. (239) 939-1148

Hours are:

Monday-Thursday 11AM-9PM
Friday-Saturday 11AM-9:30PM
Sunday 12PM-8PM

Pizza 2000

Located at 7101 Cypress Lake Dr., Suite 61 in Fort Myers. (239) 433-2344

Hours are:

Monday-Thursday 11:30AM-10PM
Friday-Saturday 11:30AM-11PM
Sunday 4-9PM

Pizza D-Lux

Located at 6810 Shoppes at Plantation Dr., #1 in Fort Myers.

Hours are:

Tuesday – Thursday 11AM-8PM
Friday 11AM-9PM
Saturday 12-8PM


Ray’s Pizza at Fort Myers Beach

Located at 118 Crescent St. on Fort Myers Beach. (239) 765-7437. Voted Best Pizza in Fort Myers 2016, 2017, and 2018.

Hours are:

Sunday-Thursday 12-10PM
Friday and Saturday 12-11PM


Authentic Chicago Pizza. Sports pub and offers carryout and delivery. Located at 15245 South Tamiami Trail, Suite #1 in Fort Myers. (239) 481-1110

Open everyday 11AM-10PM

Saucy Meatball

Located at 12401 Commerce Lakes Dr. in Fort Myers (239) 800-7172

Monday-Sunday Opens at 11AM

Sir Pizza Fort Myers Shore

Located at 13302 Palm Beach Blvd. in Fort Myers. (239) 208-4401

Hours are:

Monday – Saturday 11AM-9PM
Sunday 11AM-8PM

Starz Restaurant & Pizzeria

Located at 16681 McGregor Blvd. in Fort Myers. (239) 482-7827
Hours are:

Sunday 12-8:30PM
Monday-Thursday 11AM-8:30PM
Friday-Saturday 11AM-9:30PM

What’s your favorite topping on your pizza? Let us know in the comments below! Oh, and if I missed your favorite pizza place, make sure to let me know so I can add it to the list! 

Signature Ali

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge
Protected by WP Anti Spam